Strata Cover Australia :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Strata Water Damage Ruling Highlights Claims Communication Risk

AFCA decision shows why lot owners, brokers and insurers need clear information pathways when a unit becomes uninhabitable

Strata Water Damage Ruling Highlights Claims Communication Risk?w=400

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

A recent Australian Financial Complaints Authority ruling has put a practical spotlight on one of the most frustrating parts of strata insurance: who receives information, who acts on it, and how quickly affected lot owners are kept in the loop when damage makes a home difficult or impossible to use.

The dispute, reported by Insurance News on 22 October 2026, involved a retired couple in their seventies who lived rurally but owned a city apartment used for medical appointments and other commitments. Their apartment became uninhabitable after water damage in June 2024. Chubb’s appointed builder carried out leak detection testing but did not identify the source. The owner later made a long return trip to the apartment, investigated the problem himself and provided photos and video showing the source: loose screws between an ensuite toilet cistern and base.

AFCA found the insurer’s handling of the claim had caused an unusual degree of inconvenience and disruption. Chubb was required to pay $5,000 in non-financial loss compensation, reimburse a plumbing report fee and cover the owner’s travel costs, with interest. The ruling also noted that the apartment remained unrepaired and uninhabitable for seven months, affecting the couple’s ability to access accommodation close to medical services.

For strata communities, the case is important because it was not simply about whether water damage existed. It was also about process. Chubb said it had followed protocols for strata-managed properties by communicating through the owners corporation’s broker. AFCA accepted that strata claims often involve intermediaries, but found it would have been fair and reasonable to adjust administration so the affected owners received copies of key claim information.

That point matters for committees, strata managers and lot owners dealing with strata insurance claims. A building policy may sit with the owners corporation, but the direct consequences of delay can fall heavily on individual residents or investors. Where a unit is uninhabitable, missing reports, unclear next steps or repeated handovers can quickly turn a technical repair issue into a significant personal and financial disruption.

The broader lesson is not that every delay will lead to compensation, or that every lot owner should bypass the usual claims pathway. Rather, the ruling reinforces several practical habits:

  • record damage, access issues, health concerns and accommodation impacts as early as possible;
  • ask who is responsible for passing on builder reports, scopes of work and claim decisions;
  • flag vulnerability factors clearly, including age, illness, disability or medical access needs;
  • keep a timeline of inspections, promises, reports requested and unanswered communications;
  • escalate concerns through internal dispute resolution if a claim is stalling or information is not being shared.

For owners corporations, the case is a reminder that efficient claims handling is partly about governance. Clear communication protocols at the start of a water damage claim can reduce confusion, preserve evidence and help avoid disputes about whether the insurer, broker, strata manager, committee or affected owner was meant to act next.

Published:Wednesday, 28th Oct 2026
Author: Paige Estritori

Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.

Share this news item:

Rate this article

0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Insurance News

New Broker Code Raises the Bar for Strata Insurance Transparency
New Broker Code Raises the Bar for Strata Insurance Transparency
04 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
The final 2027 Insurance Brokers Code of Practice has put strata insurance transparency firmly in the national spotlight, with new expectations for how brokers disclose remuneration and confirm their authority when arranging cover for owners corporations. - read more
Strata Water Damage Ruling Highlights Claims Communication Risk
Strata Water Damage Ruling Highlights Claims Communication Risk
28 Oct 2026: Paige Estritori
A recent Australian Financial Complaints Authority ruling has put a practical spotlight on one of the most frustrating parts of strata insurance: who receives information, who acts on it, and how quickly affected lot owners are kept in the loop when damage makes a home difficult or impossible to use. - read more
Why Better Strata Data Is Becoming an Insurance Issue
Why Better Strata Data Is Becoming an Insurance Issue
16 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori
Urbanise’s latest market communication has again highlighted the growing importance of digital systems in strata and facilities management. While the update is not an insurance announcement, it is relevant to owners corporations, body corporates and strata committees because insurers increasingly want clear, current and usable information about the buildings they are being asked to cover. - read more
What the New NSW Disclosure Rules Mean for Strata Cover
What the New NSW Disclosure Rules Mean for Strata Cover
09 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori
The latest phase of New South Wales strata reform has brought strata insurance disclosure back into practical focus, moving the issue from policy debate to renewal-season reality for owners corporations. The changes are designed to make it clearer when a strata managing agent, broker, insurer or related party receives a commission, fee or other financial benefit connected with arranging insurance. - read more


Strata Insurance Articles

How Strata Insurance Costs Are Calculated in Australia
How Strata Insurance Costs Are Calculated in Australia
Strata insurance costs in Australia are shaped by the building, location, claims history, cover choices, excesses, legal requirements and insurer risk assessment. Understanding these factors can help owners corporations and strata committees review premiums more confidently. - read more
When to Review Strata Insurance: Valuations, Sums Insured and Underinsurance
When to Review Strata Insurance: Valuations, Sums Insured and Underinsurance
Strata insurance reviews should not only check premium changes. For owners corporations and strata committees, current reinstatement valuations, accurate sums insured and an understanding of underinsurance risk are central to keeping cover aligned with the property and its legal obligations. - read more
Strata Insurance Responsibilities for Owners Corporations, Lot Owners and Tenants
Strata Insurance Responsibilities for Owners Corporations, Lot Owners and Tenants
Strata insurance can be confusing because different parts of a property may be the responsibility of the owners corporation, individual lot owners, landlords or tenants. This guide explains the usual boundaries and where personal cover may still be needed. - read more
How to Make a Claim on Your Strata Insurance: A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Make a Claim on Your Strata Insurance: A Step-by-Step Guide
When it comes to strata insurance, making a claim can feel daunting if you're not familiar with the process. A vital first step is understanding what constitutes a claimable event. Typically, these are events that lead to damage or loss in the common areas of a property, such as fire, storm damage, or vandalism. However, each policy can vary, so it’s important to check the specifics of what your coverage includes. - read more

Knowledgebase
Umbrella Policy:
An additional insurance policy that provides extra liability coverage beyond the limits of the insured's primary policies.